Students and, likely, some teachers, as well, often
misunderstand the concept of bias. As history teachers, it is important that we
recognize that all accounts of the past are colored with bias.
The student quoted above, if taken literally, seems to be
suggesting that some sources contain bias and others do not. If we can find
some unbiased sources, this line of reasoning goes, then surely we can learn
what really happened in the past.
Studying the past, however, is much more complicated. (By
the way, I think we signal a simplistic epistemology when we use multiple
choice questions, even ‘good’ (?) ones, to assess students’ understanding of
the past.)
Lang makes the point that teachers perpetuate this view by
asking students IF a source is biased. More appropriately, teachers ought to be
asking students to find the biases in a source. Once biases are detected, the
real work begins. Students need to be challenged to consider the significance
of the biases, to account for them when making judgments about the author, the
source, and, ultimately, the historical question that is being studied.
In my previous post, I said that I enjoyed listening to the
home announcers broadcast Phillies games because of their biases. The national
broadcasters, whom I avoided, weren’t unbiased. They had different biases.
If, over time, it became apparent to me that the home
announcers were allowing their biases to cause them to distort how they were
describing the events on the baseball diamond, then, as a baseball fan who
cared about accuracy, I would likely find new announcers.
Bias may lead to distortions, but this is not automatically
the case. The claims contained in a source need to be judged against the
evidence they rely on in order for the impact of bias to be evaluated.
When our students detect bias, which is not always easy to
do, we must encourage them to see bias detection as part of a larger set of
intellectual moves performed by an historian. Yes, historians do search for bias.
But they do more than that. They consider the meaning of the bias, thinking
about how it not only reveals the author but also the author’s surroundings in
space and time.
No comments:
Post a Comment